What happens if a beneficiary dies before the testator in Scotland?

People often make a will and then outlive someone they named in it. When that happens, the gift does not simply go to the beneficiary's family. What happens next depends on the wording of the will, when it was signed and who the beneficiary was. Here is how Scots law deals with it, and what an executor needs to check.

A folded cream will tied with a sage green ribbon and a pressed white rose, an open brass pocket watch and a fountain pen on a deep green leather desk

The short answer

If a beneficiary dies before the person who made the will, their gift usually lapses. It does not pass to the beneficiary's own estate. Where the will names a substitute, such as "whom failing to her children", the substitute inherits. If not, a specific gift normally falls into the residue, and a lapsed share of residue may pass under the intestacy rules. There is one important exception: for wills signed on or after 1 November 2016, if the beneficiary was the testator's child, grandchild or other direct descendant, that person's own children step into their place unless the will says otherwise.

In Scotland, a gift in a will only takes effect on the death of the testator, the person who made the will, and only if the beneficiary is alive at that point. A beneficiary who dies first cannot inherit, so their estate cannot inherit either. The executor then has to work out where that gift goes instead. Getting this wrong is one of the more common reasons estates are distributed incorrectly, so it is worth taking care.

Start with the wording of the will

Most professionally drawn wills in Scotland deal with this situation directly. Look for these clauses first:

  • A destination over. Words such as "to my sister Ann, whom failing to her children equally" name a substitute. If Ann died first, her children take her gift.
  • A survivorship clause. Words such as "provided she survives me by 30 days" mean the beneficiary must outlive the testator by that period. If they do not, the gift fails and passes on as if they had died first.
  • A gift to a class. A gift "to such of my nephews as survive me" goes only to the nephews who are alive at the death.
  • A gift to the survivor. A gift "to A and B and the survivor of them" passes entirely to whichever of them is still alive.

If the will deals with the point clearly, the executor follows it. The rest of this guide covers what happens when it does not appoint a substitute or say what should happen. In the table, the residue means the remainder of the estate after debts, expenses and specific gifts have been paid.

When the will says nothing

Type of giftWhat usually happens if the beneficiary died firstWhere it goes
A specific item or a sum of moneyThe legacy lapsesInto the residue
The whole residue to one personThe gift of residue failsIntestacy rules
Residue "to A and B equally"The word "equally" splits the gift into separate shares, so the lapsed share does not pass to the other beneficiaryUsually intestacy
A joint gift "to A and B", with no words splitting itThe surviving beneficiary can take the whole gift, known as accretionThe survivor
A gift to the testator's child or grandchild (will signed on or after 1 November 2016)The beneficiary's own children step into their placeTheir children

A partial intestacy is where a will deals with only part of the estate. The part that is not covered passes under the intestacy rules, as if there were no will for that part. Under the rules of intestacy, that can mean a surviving spouse or civil partner, who may have prior rights, or relatives the testator never intended to benefit, receive a share. Small differences in wording, such as "equally" or "and the survivor of them", can change the result completely, so the exact words matter.

When a beneficiary's children take their place

Scots law has long recognised that most people leaving money to their children would want a grandchild to inherit if their parent died first. The rules depend on when the will was signed.

Wills signed on or after 1 November 2016

Section 6 of the Succession (Scotland) Act 2016 applies where a legacy is left to a direct descendant of the testator, such as a son, daughter or grandchild, or to a group made up only of direct descendants. If that person dies before the legacy vests, their own children or other descendants (their "issue") take the share the beneficiary would have received. The rule does not apply where the will shows a different intention, for example a survivorship clause or a named substitute. It only applies where the testator also died on or after 1 November 2016.

Wills signed before 1 November 2016

Older wills are governed by an old common law rule known by its Latin name, the conditio si institutus sine liberis decesserit. It is a presumption that the testator would have wanted the children of a predeceasing beneficiary to inherit. It applied to gifts to the testator's own descendants and, in some circumstances, to nephews and nieces. Because it is only a presumption, its effect in a particular will can be open to argument, and legal advice is often needed.

A worked example

Margaret signed her will in 2019, leaving the residue of her estate "to my children, Susan, David and Fiona, equally". David died in 2024, leaving two daughters. Margaret died in 2026. Because David was Margaret's son and the will was signed after November 2016, David's daughters take his one third share between them, a sixth each. If Margaret's will had instead left the residue "to my sister Ann and my brother Tom equally", and Tom had died first, the new rule would not apply, because a brother is not a direct descendant. Tom's half would usually fall into intestacy.

If the beneficiary dies after the testator but before the estate is distributed

The position is quite different where the beneficiary was alive when the testator died, but died before the estate was paid out. In most cases the gift vested on the testator's death, so it belongs to the beneficiary's estate. It is paid to the beneficiary's own executors and then passes under their will or the intestacy rules.

  • Survivorship clauses still matter. If the will required the beneficiary to survive by 30 days and they died within that period, the gift fails.
  • Their executor deals with it. The testator's executor pays the gift to the beneficiary's executor, who may need their own Confirmation.
  • Inheritance tax relief may apply. If both estates pay inheritance tax and the deaths are within five years, quick succession relief can reduce the tax on the second estate. Our guide to inheritance tax in Scotland explains the main allowances.
  • A deed of variation is still possible. The beneficiary's executors can sometimes redirect the gift within two years of the first death. See our guide to deeds of variation.

When the order of deaths is unclear

Sometimes two people die together, for example in an accident, and nobody can say who died first. For deaths on or after 1 November 2016, section 9 of the Succession (Scotland) Act 2016 says that where the order of deaths cannot be established, neither person is treated as having survived the other. Each estate is then dealt with as if the other person had died first. Where a will requires a beneficiary to survive for a set period and it is uncertain whether they did, they are treated as not having survived.

  • No will at all. Under the intestacy rules, if one of the children of the deceased died first, that child's own descendants represent them and share what the child would have received. Our guide to next of kin explains the wider order.
  • Legal rights. The children of a child who died first can also claim that child's share of legal rights. Legal rights come only from moveable property, such as money and shares, not heritable property such as the house. Our guide on whether you can disinherit a child in Scotland explains legal rights in full.
  • A former spouse or civil partner. For deaths on or after 1 November 2016, if a will made before a divorce or dissolution leaves something to the former spouse, they are treated as having died before the testator, unless the will says otherwise. The gift passes to any substitute or falls into residue. Our guides to contesting a will and marriage, divorce and wills cover this.
  • Jointly owned homes. A survivorship destination in the title deeds works separately from the will. Our guide to jointly owned houses explains how.

What the executor should do before they distribute the estate

  1. Confirm the dates of death. Get the death certificate or a record of the beneficiary's death, and note whether it was before or after the testator's death.
  2. Read the will closely. Look for substitutes, survivorship clauses, class gifts and words such as "equally" or "and the survivor".
  3. Check when the will was signed. A will signed before 1 November 2016 is subject to the older rules.
  4. Draw up a family tree. If the beneficiary was a direct descendant, find out whether they left children of their own.
  5. Work out where each lapsed gift goes. Residue, a substitute, the beneficiary's children or intestacy.
  6. Take advice from a solicitor where the wording is unclear. An executor who pays the wrong person can be personally liable. In difficult cases, a court can decide who is entitled.
  7. Record it in the estate accounts. Show beneficiaries how each share was worked out.

None of this changes the normal order of work. The executor still has to apply for Confirmation, the Scottish equivalent of probate, at the sheriff court, collect the bank accounts and other assets of the deceased person, and pay any debt owed to a creditor before they distribute the estate. Executors usually wait until six months after the date of death before the final distribution of the estate, so that creditors have time to claim. Where each lapsed gift goes is settled at that stage, when the executor works out the value of the estate available and each share of the estate. Our executor checklist shows where this fits in the wider process.

Review your own will

If someone named in your will has died, it is a good time to review it. A short survivorship clause, a named substitute for each main gift and a clear residue clause can stop a gift falling into intestacy. Where family circumstances have changed, a new will is usually simpler than relying on the default rules, and it is a good moment to look at your wider estate planning. If you want someone to have the use of a home for life before it passes to others, a liferent may suit.

How we can help

We read the will, check the dates and the family tree, and tell the executor exactly who is entitled to each gift, before anything is paid out. See our estate administration, intestate estates and executor advice services, or talk to our executry solicitors in Glasgow, Paisley, Renfrew, Barrhead, East Kilbride, Hamilton, Motherwell or Dumfries. Your first appointment is free.

Frequently asked questions

Does a gift in a will lapse if the beneficiary dies first in Scotland?

Usually, yes. A gift only takes effect if the beneficiary is alive when the person who made the will dies. If the beneficiary died first, the gift lapses and goes to any substitute named in the will. If there is none, a specific gift normally falls into the residue, and a lapsed share of residue may pass under the intestacy rules.

Do grandchildren inherit if their parent dies before the grandparent?

Often, yes. For wills signed on or after 1 November 2016, where a gift is left to the testator's child or other direct descendant who dies first, that person's own children take their share, unless the will shows a different intention. For older wills, a similar common law presumption usually applies to gifts to the testator's descendants.

What happens if a beneficiary dies after the testator but before the estate is paid out?

In most cases the gift vested when the testator died, so it belongs to the beneficiary's estate. It is paid to the beneficiary's executors and passes under their will or the intestacy rules. The exception is where the will required the beneficiary to survive for a set period, such as 30 days, and they did not.

What happens if the main beneficiary of the residue dies first?

If the will names no substitute, the gift of residue fails and that part of the estate passes under the intestacy rules, as a partial intestacy. The exception is a gift to the testator's direct descendant under a will signed on or after 1 November 2016, where that beneficiary's children take their place.

What is a survivorship clause in a Scottish will?

It is a clause saying a beneficiary must outlive the testator by a set period, often 30 days, to inherit. If they do not, the gift passes as if they had died first. It avoids an inheritance passing through two estates in quick succession, and it displaces the rule that lets a descendant's children take their place.

Need help with an estate?

Our executry solicitors can take the whole process off your hands, or answer a single question. Your first appointment is free.

This guide is general information about Scots law, correct at the date shown. It is not legal advice for your circumstances.

Talk to us today

Talk to us about a gift in a will

Call us on 0141 471 9166 and tell us a little about the estate. One of our executry solicitors will talk you through the next steps. Your first appointment is free and there is no obligation.

If you can, have the will, the death certificate and the date the beneficiary died to hand. If you do not have them yet, that is fine. Our guides explain how to find a will and the rules of intestacy.

  • Phone 0141 471 9166
  • Office 34 Woodlands Road, Glasgow G3 6UR
  • Hours Monday and Friday 9am to 5pm, Tuesday to Thursday 8am to 6pm

The quickest way to reach us

0141 471 9166

Call to book your free first appointment, at one of our offices or by phone.

Please note that legal aid is not available for this service.

Call us Free appointment